If you're not familiar with the Michael Yon brouhaha in Afghanistan, here's a good
rundown. Short version: embedded journalist and author of
Moment of Truth in Iraq
makes a cryptic post on Facebook, saying General McChrystal is in over his head. Milblogging community reacts, generally stating that Yon is burned out and needs a break. Yon replies, stating that milbloggers are largely a "hurricane of hot air."
Unlike a lot of milbloggers, I don't know Yon. I've read his stuff, and while it's a little preachy for my taste, it's generally a decent read. And he may very well be right about General McChrystal, I have no idea. But that doesn't change the fact that he's displaying classic dick tendencies right now, something, some of you may remember, I did myself, back in 2008.
First, I'm inclined to point out that the term "hurricane of hot air" is a bit redundant, but that's beside the point. The Facebook post in question, the ones since, his updates on his website ... they're now all about him. The personal story of Yon getting picked on and shut out of information sessions has taken precedence over the story of the whole; i.e. the war. He hints at grander conspiracy, does his best martyr impression, and promises revenge. These are classic burnout symptoms.
When I posted
this in 2008, I was in the same state. Exhausted. Strung out. Convinced no one cared about the war effort except me and those immediately around me. Sure, my post had some good points, but that doesn't mean I should have posted it. Yon may very well be right about General McChrystal (though I doubt it - everyone I know who works/worked for him is convinced he's a national treasure), but he of all people knows the power of the internet. I mocked middle management and bureaucracy. He's calling into question the leadership and prowess of our top man in the war. For all the flag-waving and chest-beating that usually peppers Yon's words, this sudden 180 screams of a burnout desperate for attention, and even more desperate for a break.
And
then Yon attacked the milblogging community, most of whom treaded on this subject very carefully and tactfully. And these are the people that
made him. That donation button on the side of his website? Who do you think was clicking it all those years, Code Pink? Who helped spread his message and accounts? Not the mainstream media. And this is how he repays them? Again, classic burnout syndrome - lashing out at those who helped him the most.
Yon also attempts to have a junk-measuring contest with the milblogging community, by self-righteously claiming that no one has spent the amount of time in theater that he has. Maybe true, maybe not. Kind of irrelevant, though. You're a journalist dude, not a soldier. You can leave whenever you want, come and go as you please, and don't spend your days filling sandbags, nor your nights pulling guard duty, shivering on a roof. No matter how much you want to be, you're not one of them anymore.
One last caveat - I don't know General McChrystal, either. Closest I ever came to him was having to deal with his black ops teams in Iraq, usually when they were blowing stuff up and giving us landowners serious heartburn. So this isn't an Andrew Exum-Jon Krakauer thing, debating whether or not grandpa is brilliant or a conspiracist. I have no dog in this fight. I'm just a dude with a book, a book that happened because of milbloggers, telling another dude with a book, a book that also happened because of milbloggers, that he's being a dick.
My mid-tour leave in the Mediterranean cured a lot of my ills (the dickish ones and otherwise) back in 2008. Strolls along the beach, beers in the park, and a lot of sleep. Here's hoping Yon gets some of the same soon, and then returns back to his actual job in Afghanistan - war reporting.